Vinyl and aluminum are the two frame materials behind nearly every impact window installed in South Florida. Both can be rated for the High Velocity Hurricane Zone, both come in the major styles, and both are sold by the brands we install. The right choice comes down to where your home sits, the size of your openings and what you want from the frame.
Side by side
| Aluminum | Vinyl | |
|---|---|---|
| Strength | Strongest; slim profiles even on large openings | Thicker profiles; large openings may need reinforcement |
| Salt air | Excellent with a marine-grade finish and stainless hardware | Unaffected by salt; hardware still needs stainless |
| Insulation | Good with thermal breaks and Low-E glass | Better; vinyl does not conduct heat |
| Maintenance | Rinse and inspect finish | Rinse; never needs paint |
| Appearance | Thin frames, more glass, many colors and woodgrain | Thicker frames, white and a growing range of colors |
| Cost | Usually higher | Usually lower |
| Brands we install | ES Windows, Mr. Glass, PGT WinGuard Aluminum, ECO, EMC, GIG | PGT WinGuard Vinyl |
When aluminum is the right call
- Waterfront, beachfront and Keys homes where frames face constant salt spray
- Large sliding doors, picture windows and tall openings that need a slim, rigid frame
- Modern and Mediterranean homes where thin sightlines and dark or bronze finishes matter
- Condos and commercial buildings, where aluminum is the standard
When vinyl is the right call
- Inland homes in Kendall, Pembroke Pines, Doral and western Broward where energy performance matters more than salt resistance
- Homeowners who want the lowest cooling bills and never want to repaint
- Standard-size openings on single-family homes
- Budgets where the price difference lets you do the whole house at once
What does not change
Both materials use the same laminated impact glass, carry the same Florida Product Approval or Miami-Dade NOA, earn the same insurance opening protection credit, and are installed to the same approved drawings. The glass package and the installation matter more than the frame material for storm protection. Compare the brands.
Frequently asked questions
Are vinyl impact windows approved for Miami-Dade?
Yes. PGT WinGuard Vinyl includes HVHZ-approved products. We confirm the approval for each product on your quote.
Which lasts longer, vinyl or aluminum?
Both last for decades when installed correctly. Aluminum needs its finish protected from salt; vinyl needs nothing beyond cleaning.
Is vinyl cheaper than aluminum?
Usually, yes, which is why many inland homeowners choose it for whole-house projects.
Can I mix frames on one house?
Yes, though most homeowners keep one material for a consistent look.
Which is better for noise?
The glass package drives noise reduction more than the frame. Laminated or insulated laminated glass in either frame performs well.

